I build custom websites for a living, so you’d expect this to be a hit piece on Wix and Squarespace. It isn’t. I’ve told people to use a site builder, and I’d do it again. They’re genuinely good at what they’re for.
What they’re not good at is being clear about what you give up. So here’s the comparison I wish someone had shown me: what each option costs over three years, how fast it is, what you actually own, and when each one is the right call.
What you actually pay
Builders look cheap because the number on the pricing page is monthly. Here’s what the plans cost at the time of writing, in October 2026. Prices change, so check the links, but the shape of it doesn’t.
| Plan | Per month, paid yearly | Per month, paid monthly | Notes |
|---|---|---|---|
| Wix Light | about $17 | more | 2 GB storage, no online payments |
| Wix Core | about $29 | more | Basic online store |
| Wix Business | about $39 | more | Full store features |
| Squarespace Basic | $19 | $25 | 2% fee on store sales |
| Squarespace Core | $29 | $39 | No Squarespace fee on sales |
| Squarespace Plus | $49 | $65 | Where available |
| Custom (gbfm) | one-time build, quoted | hosting, often $0–20 | Optional monthly maintenance |
Sources: wix.com/plans and squarespace.com/pricing, October 2026. Wix shows yearly prices only; monthly billing is higher on both. Neither includes a domain name, which runs roughly $15–25 a year wherever you buy it.
The mid-tier plan most businesses end up on is about $29 a month. Over three years that’s roughly $1,050 if you pay yearly, or about $1,400 month to month, before any paid apps, templates or add-ons. And at the end of the three years you don’t own anything. Stop paying and the site is gone.
A custom site flips the shape: more up front, then very little. Hosting for a well-built site is cheap or free, because it doesn’t need a server doing work on every visit. You pay once for the build, then only for the domain and whatever upkeep you want.
How fast they are
This is the part the pricing pages don’t mention. Builders carry the code for every feature they offer, whether your site uses it or not, and it shows up in Google’s speed test. In 2024 the HTTP Archive measured millions of sites and found the median phone performance score was 55 for Wix and 30 for Squarespace. Half of the sites on each platform scored lower than that.
A custom site is as fast as the person building it makes it. That cuts both ways: I’ve seen hand-built sites that were slower than Wix. But a custom build has no ceiling. Every site in my gallery is tested at 100 on the same Google tool, and here’s what that number means.
median phone score, Squarespace sites, 2024
median phone score, Wix sites, 2024
every site in my gallery, tested the same way
Source: HTTP Archive Web Almanac 2024, CMS chapter.
What you own
With a builder you rent. The design, the pages, the hosting and the software are one bundle that lives on their servers. Wix doesn’t let you take your site to another host at all. Squarespace lets you export some of your content, but not the design, and not everything.
That’s fine right up until you want to leave. Then your choice is to rebuild from scratch somewhere else or keep paying. Builders know this; it’s the business model.
A custom site is a folder of files. You can host it anywhere, hand it to any developer, or keep it exactly as it is for ten years. I give clients the files and the logins. Here’s what owning your website actually means, and the questions to ask whoever builds it.
Design and what it can do
Builders give you hundreds of templates and a drag-and-drop editor, which is great for getting something presentable up in an afternoon. The trade-off is that every site is a variation on the same handful of layouts, and the moment you want something the template doesn’t do, you’re either installing an app that slows the site down or giving up on the idea.
A custom build does whatever the business needs: a quote calculator, a booking flow that matches how you actually book, a gallery that loads fast with 200 photos, a page that looks like nothing else in your industry. The limit is the brief, not the platform.
Your time
The real price of a builder isn’t the $29 a month, it’s the weekend. Someone has to pick the template, write the copy, resize the photos, fight the editor, and then keep it updated. For a lot of owners that someone is them, at 11pm.
With a custom build you hand over your logo, photos and a sense of what the site is for, and get a finished site back. I write the copy if you don’t have it. The only ongoing time is telling me what to change.
When a builder is the right call
I mean this. A builder is the right choice if:
- You’re just starting and need something up this week for very little money.
- You’re testing an idea and might not be doing this in six months.
- You enjoy tinkering with your own site and would rather do it yourself.
- The site is a brochure that nobody will find through Google anyway, and speed doesn’t affect your business.
When custom is the right call
- You rely on Google to bring you customers, so speed and search matter.
- You want to own the site and never be locked in.
- You need something a template can’t do.
- You’d rather not maintain it yourself, or pay monthly forever.
- Your business has outgrown a site that looks like everyone else’s.
Five questions to ask before you decide
- How much of my business comes through Google, and how much more could?
- If I stop paying, what do I keep?
- What will this site need to do in two years that it doesn’t do today?
- Who’s going to update it, and how many hours a month is that?
- What does it cost over three years, not one month?
Answer those honestly and the choice usually makes itself. If it points to a builder, go build it. If it points to custom, tell me about the business and I’ll give you one all-in number.
Cheap to start and cheap to own are different things. Make sure you know which one you’re buying.
Want me to look at your site?
Send me the address and I’ll tell you what’s slowing it down, what it’s missing, and what I’d fix first. No charge, no pressure.